I first encountered this thought as a young teenager reading Ursula K. LeGuin’s The Dispossessed. In her fascinating tale which I recently re-read, she contrasts two fictional societies – one very much like ours and another described as an ambiguous utopia.
In the world that mirrors our own, citizens are concerned with possession and the striving toward increased wealth in order to purchase more things. Class hierarchies, competitiveness, and power struggles are the norm of everyday life. Most poignant and central is the belief that happiness comes from externals such as possessions, stature, and health.
In the utopian world, inhabitants are focused not on ownership, but by how they relate to others and what they can do for them. In fact, there is no ownership. Everything is shared. “All you have is what you are, and what you give.” In this, they are free.
When we own things, attachment naturally follows. Pronouns like “mine” and “yours” frame our possessive communications, and in some cases we go to great lengths to “protect” what is “ours”. Homeowners and parents know this very well. Continue reading